Field Notes
The real cost of a free server
A friend once asked us whether they should accept a free two-socket server from their employer's hardware refresh. The honest answer was: it depends what your electricity costs. So we measured one.
Free hardware is the most expensive hardware in this hobby. The purchase price is zero, so the only cost anyone thinks about is the one that never shows up on a receipt: the electricity it uses every hour of every day, and the heat and noise that come with it.
What we measured
The same hardware refresh produced a spare, which was donated to the Bench: a typical off-lease 2U server with two CPUs, 128 GB of memory, a hardware RAID card, four spinning drives and redundant power supplies. Plugged into a wall meter and left idle with a hypervisor running a few quiet VMs, it drew 148 W.
For comparison, a current small form factor PC with 64 GB of memory and an NVMe SSD, running the same VMs, idled at 12 W.
| Free 2U server | Mini PC | |
|---|---|---|
| Idle draw at the wall | 148 W | 12 W |
| Energy per year, always on | 1,296 kWh | 105 kWh |
| Cost per year at 17 cents per kWh | about $220 | about $18 |
| Cost over three years | about $661 | about $54 |
| Heat output | about 505 BTU per hour | about 41 BTU per hour |
| Noise | Audible through a closed door | Inaudible across the room |
At that electricity price, the free server costs roughly $600 more to run over three years than the mini PC, which is more than the mini PC costs to buy. In regions with higher prices, the gap is wider. Run your own numbers with our Power Cost Calculator; the rule of thumb is that every 10 W running all year is about 87.6 kWh.
Taming the beast
We did not stop at the first measurement. A few changes made a large difference:
- Firmware power profile. Switching from maximum performance to an operating-system-controlled profile cut idle draw by 18 W.
- Fan profile. Resetting fans from full speed to automatic saved several watts and most of the noise.
- Removing the RAID card and one power supply. We did not need hardware RAID, and a second power supply idling for redundancy draws real power. Together they saved about 15 W.
- Low-power CPUs. Swapping to the low-power variants of the same processor family, which cost very little used, saved a further 12 W at idle.
The tuned server idled at 96 W. Better, and now around $143 a year to run instead of $220, but still eight times the mini PC.
Scheduling helps too. A lab server that shuts down at midnight after its backups and powers on at seven in the morning runs about 70 percent of the hours, and costs about 70 percent as much. See Racks, Power and Cooling for scheduled power-on that works reliably.
When the free server is still the right answer
None of this means big servers are a mistake. They are the right choice when you need what only they offer:
- Many drive bays for a large storage pool.
- Lots of memory for memory-hungry learning projects, such as private cloud platforms or large container clusters.
- Enterprise features you want to learn, such as management controllers, redundant power and hardware you will meet at work.
- Cheap or included electricity, which changes the math entirely.
- A cold climate, where the heat is not wasted in winter. In summer, of course, you may pay twice: once to make the heat and once to remove it.
If you take one, measure it before you commit, tune it as above, and consider running it only when you are actively using it.
Questions to ask before accepting
- What does it draw at idle, at the wall, with the drives I would actually use?
- What does that cost me per year at my real electricity price?
- Where will it live, and can the people I live with tolerate the noise and heat?
- Is its management controller fully licensed, and are firmware updates freely available?
- Could a smaller machine do the same job for the workloads I really run?
Our friend took their server too, by the way. They ran it for a winter in an unheated garage as a learning lab, measured the bill, and replaced it in spring with two mini PCs and a small NAS. They said it was the most educational free gift they ever received.